971 E 9th St, Chico, CA 95928
Buying a First Car
Recently, the youngest member of our team purchased her very first car. Of course, everyone here at Payless 4 Wheel Drive & Auto Center had to put in their two cents—not only about what she should buy, but also by inspecting every "new-to-her" vehicle that became a possibility.
Her criteria were pretty straightforward:
1. Reliability
The vehicle had to be dependable. No one wants to be stranded on the side of the road late at night or stuck in a college parking lot waiting for a tow truck. This was especially important since she'll be driving to and from college for the next several years. Ideally, the car needed to last through at least four years of college—and hopefully graduate school as well.
2. Affordability
The purchase price had to fit within a limited college-student budget. Replacement parts needed to be readily available and reasonably priced, and our team wanted a vehicle that we could completely service in-house without requiring specialty shops or dealer-only repairs.
3. Great Fuel Economy
Like most college students, she wanted to spend as little as possible at the gas pump. With California fuel prices, every mile per gallon matters. We set our sights on vehicles capable of achieving 35 MPG or better.
4. Four Doors (Five Preferred)
She needed enough room to haul livestock equipment, equine tack, such as saddles, and everything else that comes with spending time around horses and livestock. A hatchback or wagon would be ideal.
5. A Manual Transmission
Everyone here at the shop loves driving a stick shift. Manual transmissions are generally simpler, less expensive to repair than automatics, and they're just plain fun to drive.
Naturally, our youngest team member had other ideas.
She really wanted either a pickup truck that could pull her parents' trailer or a sleek, sporty red hatchback.
Unfortunately, neither option fit her budget.
A truck simply couldn't meet her fuel economy goals, and every attractive manual-transmission hatchback we found was priced well beyond what she could afford.
Then we discovered another challenge.
Finding any vehicle with a manual transmission was surprisingly difficult.
The entire team searched listings within a 100-mile radius, filtering for manual transmissions first. Compared to just ten years ago, there simply weren't many options.
Mini Coopers appeared in our searches over and over again. Our mechanic, James, absolutely loves working on Minis and has owned a few himself. She quickly became a fan of the Mini Cooper Countryman.
On paper, the Countryman checked almost every box.
Unfortunately, it missed one important category: affordability.
Every Countryman we found was above her budget, and Mini Cooper parts tend to be more expensive than many comparable vehicles.
So, the search continued.
Fords.
Chevrolets.
Toyotas.
Hondas.
Weeks went by, and we started wondering if she'd ever find a vehicle that checked all the boxes. The conversation even shifted toward saving for another year or giving up on the dream of owning a manual transmission altogether.
Then the nearly perfect car practically fell into our lap.
One of our customers decided to sell her 2002 Honda Civic sedan equipped with a 5-speed manual transmission .
At first, we were hesitant as it was 24 years old and it had nearly 190,000 miles on the odometer.
But once we looked it over, our concerns quickly disappeared.
The car had been serviced regularly throughout its life. Many of the major wear items had already been replaced. The tires still had plenty of life remaining, the interior was exceptionally clean, and although the California sun had faded the paint, the car drove beautifully.
There were no unusual noises.
No shakes.
No rattles.
And best of all...
It was under budget .
Before making a decision, our youngest team member sat down with our technicians and parts manager to discuss the pros and cons.
Surprisingly, there weren't many cons to discuss.
Other than the fact that it wasn't the sporty red hatchback she'd been dreaming about, everyone agreed it was an excellent choice.
Our technicians explained that the Civic is one of the least expensive vehicles to maintain. Parts are widely available, repairs are generally straightforward, and because the Honda Civic has been one of America's most popular cars for decades, virtually every repair has been done—and documented—thousands of times before.
As for the mileage?
No one was overly concerned.
A well-maintained Honda with 190,000 miles is often a much better investment than a neglected vehicle with half the mileage. Regular maintenance and proper care are far more important than the number displayed on the odometer.
After weighing all the facts, she decided to go for it.
She bought the Honda Civic.
Did she make the right decision?
Only time will tell.
Buying any used vehicle involves some risk. There are never any guarantees. The best way to minimize that risk is to do your homework. Research the year, make, and model. Review maintenance records. Have the vehicle inspected by a trusted repair shop. Understand what repairs have already been completed and what maintenance may be coming due.
In the end, the goal isn't to find a perfect used car.
The goal is to find the best-maintained vehicle that fits your needs, your budget, and your lifestyle.
Sometimes, the smartest choice isn't the newest, the flashiest, or the one you've always dreamed about.
Sometimes, it's the dependable Honda Civic that quietly checks every box.












